STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. – The thriller of who paid for the billboard supporting Vito Fossella for borough president final yr has been solved.
On Thursday, the New York Metropolis Marketing campaign Finance Board (CFB) held a public assembly to vote on violations and penalties for impartial spending teams in the course of the 2021 normal election. The group of impartial spenders included Ben-Chris Realty LLC, who the Marketing campaign Finance Board alleged didn’t file a essential disclosure report.
In June 2021, the Marketing campaign Finance Board stated it grew to become conscious of an commercial selling the marketing campaign of Vito Fossella for Staten Island Borough President; the commercial was the billboard close to the Outerbridge Crossing.
Fossella’s marketing campaign denied duty for the billboard.
An investigation by the Marketing campaign Finance Board decided that Ben-Chris Realty LLC — which data present is owned by Benedetto Casale, proprietor of Casale Tile – paid $1,400 for the billboard that was put in on or about June 1, 2021.
Town Marketing campaign Finance Board (CFB) regulation states that every part contributing to a marketing campaign should be reported, together with that which was personally paid for; donated monies had been used; or companies had been donated, referred to as in-kind contributions.
CFB guidelines state: “For every in-kind contribution, candidates should preserve a written report that gives the date the contribution was made, the identify and residential deal with of the contributor, an in depth description of the products or companies supplied, the truthful market worth of the contribution, and such additional info and documentation essential to point out how the truthful market worth of the contribution was decided.”
There may be an in-kind contribution most of $1,500 per particular person or enterprise.
CFB additionally states, “You need to disclose all contributions and expenditures within the disclosure assertion due instantly after they’re acquired/incurred in our monetary disclosure web-based software, C-SMART. If contributions are usually not disclosed for the interval by which they had been acquired, they won’t be eligible for matching funds.”
BILLBOARD NOT FOUND TO BE LINKED TO FOSSELLA CAMPAIGN, CFB SAYS
The investigation confirmed the expenditure was made independently of the Fossella marketing campaign, the Marketing campaign Finance Board stated.
Primarily based on the date the expenditure was paid for, it was required to be reported to the Marketing campaign Finance Board on June 11, 2021, however was not disclosed till November 29, 2021, which is in violation of the company’s disclosure guidelines.
The Marketing campaign Finance Board assessed a penalty of $350 for failing to reveal the expenditure on time.
Casale didn’t present up for Thursday’s listening to with the Marketing campaign Finance Board, the company stated.
A girl who answered the telephone at Casale Tile stated they had been unaware of any assembly or court docket date on Thursday.
“He thought he was simply donating it and that was it,” the lady stated. “[Benedetto] stated he was simply making an attempt to do one of the best that he may assist one of the best particular person for the job.”
BILLBOARD MAY HAVE BEEN REASON FOSSELLA WAS DENIED MATCHING FUNDS DURING CAMPAIGN
Throughout Fossella’s marketing campaign, the then-borough president candidate didn’t obtain public matching funds for all however one of many fee distributions.
To qualify for public matching funds, borough president candidates should elevate no less than $10,000 in whole contributions from 100 or extra particular person Staten Island donors.
Along with the fundraising threshold, candidates should additionally report all monetary marketing campaign exercise by way of expenditure and in-kind contribution experiences; report employment info for a portion of its matching claims and supply full and correct backup documentation for a portion of its matching claims.
A supply with information of the marketing campaign beforehand instructed the Advance/SILive.com the billboard was not related to the Fossella marketing campaign. “It was a spontaneous present of assist, very similar to a hand-crafted garden signal or social media put up,” the supply stated.
Fossella’s workplace didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark concerning the billboard.
FOLLOW KRISTIN F. DALTON ON TWITTER.